Aquatic Life Institute Releases Rankings in 3rd Annual Aquaculture Certification Benchmark

Aquatic Life Institute (ALI) is thrilled to announce the release of the 3rd Aquaculture Certification Schemes Benchmark: Aquatic Animal Welfare. This annual report evaluates the welfare standards of 8 global seafood certification schemes and, for the first time, an international ratings agency—Monterey Bay Aquarium’s Seafood Watch program. This year's benchmark evaluates an additional certifier, the Soil Association Organic Standards for Great Britain Aquaculture, thus expanding our assessment to include more certifiers and continuing our commitment to drive improvements for aquatic animal welfare.

This benchmark will continue to serve as a valuable tool for businesses, helping them make informed decisions about sourcing sustainable and ethical seafood, while also providing clear guidelines for the evaluated bodies, offering actionable insights on how they can improve their welfare standards.

What We Measure

The report assesses five key welfare criteria:
 

1. Water Quality

2. Stocking Density and Space Requirements

3. Environmental Enrichment

4. Feed Composition

5. Stunning and Slaughter

Additionally, certifiers were evaluated on a "Neglected Species Prohibitions" category, with up to 3 bonus points for prohibiting:
 

1. Octopus farming

2. Insect use in aquafeed

3. Eyestalk ablation in shrimp farming

Key Findings

• 6 out of 9 prohibit eyestalk ablation in shrimp farming: This is a significant step forward in addressing one of the unethical practices in shrimp farming, which involves removing part of the shrimp’s eyestalk to increase reproduction rates.

• 5 out of 9 perform well in stocking density and space requirements: Adequate space and lower stocking densities are critical to improving the welfare of farmed aquatic animals, reducing stress and disease, and promoting healthier environments.

• 4 out of 9 take a stance against octopus farming: Building on last year's commitments from RSPCA and Friend of the Sea to ban octopus farming, Soil Association has also prohibited octopus farming and Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) released a statement that they are not considering the certification of any farmed octopus products for the foreseeable future.

• Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) Ranks First: The Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) Farm Standard secured the top spot in this year’s benchmark, largely due to its stance against certifying octopus farming. In their September 2024 statement, ASC affirmed, "Currently, and for the foreseeable future, responsible cephalopod farming is not being considered by ASC," underscoring their commitment to ethical aquaculture practices.
  
  “Aquaculture Stewardship Council is happy to take the leading position among all aquaculture certifications, standards and ratings benchmarked by Aquatic Life Institute (ALI) for the second year in a row. This proves ASC’s commitment towards the improvement of fish welfare through rigorous monitoring and evaluation requirements for seafood farms and key welfare indicators” - Maria Filipa Castanheira, Fish Welfare Coordinator, ASC

Why It Matters

The eight global seafood certification schemes and one international ratings agency evaluated in this report collectively oversee the welfare of billions of aquatic animals each year. This highlights the immense impact that these bodies have on countless individual lives, underscoring the critical role of benchmark evaluations like this one in driving higher welfare standards across the industry.

By publishing these results, we foster competition among certifiers and ratings agencies to improve their standards year over year, ensuring better conditions for farmed aquatic animals globally. This public accountability pushes the industry toward a more compassionate and sustainable future.

We invite you to explore the full report and the summary report.